House Floor Vote / April 23, 2018

HF 3280: Repeal existing wild rice sulfate water quality standard

In the 1970s the Minnesota Pollution Control Agency (MPCA) developed a water quality standard to regulate sulfate discharges. The standard was set at 10 mg/L. Within the last several years, at the direction of the legislature, the MPCA began efforts to revise the sulfate standard. After new science was published that created a more precise formula for determining how much sulfate a waterbody can safely handle, the MPCA began the formal rulemaking process. During the formal rulemaking process, the Office of Administrative Hearings (OHA) disapproved of the proposed new wild rice sulfate rule submitted by the MPCA. The OHA’s disapproval concentrated on the challenges the agency would have to apply the new science and to affordably implement the new rule. In response to the OHA’s disapproval the MPCA, on April 26th, withdrew the proposed rule from the formal rulemaking process.

At the time HF 3280 was voted on, the MPCA had not yet withdrawn the new wild rice sulfate. Once the MPCA pulled the proposal from the rulemaking process, the portions of the bill concerning rulemaking were no longer relevant.

One part of the bill that is still relevant is the part of the bill that repeals the existing 10 mg/L water quality standard, and leaves nothing in its place. If the bill becomes law the MPCA will no longer have any water quality standards to protect wild rice from sulfate pollution. This leaves upcoming water quality permitting decisions on Polymet copper nickel mine and other future mining operations near the Boundary Waters in question.

The House passed the bill with 78 “Yes” votes and 45 “No” votes.

The Senate adopted the already passed House language on April 30th, and passed the bill with 38 “Yes” votes and 28 “No” votes.

If you would like to let your representative know what you think of this vote, you can send them a quick note by clicking HERE.

What Would Happen?

A “Yes” vote would repeal the existing wild rice sulfate water quality standard and move the bill onto the Senate for concurrence.

A “No” vote would leave the existing wild rice sulfate standard in place and would not move the bill onto the Senate.

How The House Voted

A “Yes” vote would repeal the existing wild rice sulfate water quality standard and move the bill onto the Senate for concurrence.


How The House Voted On This Issue

Contact Us

We would love to hear from you!

Conservation Minnesota
1101 West River Parkway, Suite 250
Minneapolis, Minnesota 55415
612-767-2444 phone
612-677-3278 fax

Like us on Facebook

Follow us on Twitter

RT @BrooklynPark: Brooklyn Park just completed the largest solar panel project of any Minnesota city ☀️ Thank you to our supporters, @GovTi…

July 8th, 2019 5:50 PM